Whole New Mess

Whole New Mess was recorded over ten days in October 2018 with engineer Michael Harris. The pair worked in isolation in the town of Anacortes, Washington, recording in a converted Catholic church.[4] Olsen would use the church's corridors to create a natural echo effect on her vocals.[4]

The album was recorded prior to Olsen's 2019 studio album, All Mirrors, which features many of the same compositions in a different form: "When we made [Whole New Mess], I was still processing a lot of the songs, so for me, it’s harder to listen to this record than it is for me to listen to All Mirrors. When I recorded All Mirrors, other people had their hands in the pot, which separated me from the songs. I could get into them in a distant way. On Whole New Mess I’m feeling every feeling that they evoke."[4]

The album was written following the collapse of a romantic relationship, with Olsen noting: "I was really depressed. I had no idea whether the songs were good. They were just about my life. I could have recorded them at home and kept them as demos, but I knew Michael [Harris] was someone I could be depressed in front of, who would help me to explore it in different ways. It was such an emotional process."[4]

The album was critically acclaimed upon its release. At Metacritic, based on fifteen professional reviews, it received a weighted average score of 84 out of 100.[5]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
AnyDecentMusic?	7.6/10[6]
Metacritic	84/100[5]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[7]
Consequence of Sound	B+[8]
DIY	[9]
Exclaim!	8/10[10]
The Line of Best Fit	7.5/10[11]
Loud and Quiet	9/10[12]
NME	[13]
Paste	7.0/10[14]
Pitchfork	8.0/10[15]
Rolling Stone	[16]